Asked journalist David Yarwood 50 years ago exactly this month. This old school well-researched article was published in the Northwich Guardian on 9 November 1973. It is transcribed below and is certainly worth a read for the background, insights and local names.
See here for a full transcription of the article, see here. Names from the 1970s include: Wilf Isherwood, Edward Isherwood, David Goulbourn, David Burne, Grey Hodnett, Adrian Peters, Jim Wright, Bernard Hurst, Jack Thompson and Cecil Bland.
What is Soul Caking?
For those unfamiliar with the term, Soul Caking is a custom that dates back centuries, and the Antrobus Soul Cakers are one of the very few surviving groups. The Antrobus gang perform every year in November around the pubs in Antrobus and the surrounding villages.
The play involves a number of unusual characters and features a sword fight between King George and the Black Prince, with the Black Prince being killed and then brought back to life by a doctor. The last characters to enter the play are the Wild Horse of Antrobus and his Driver. All the parts, played by men, are thought to represent the souls of the dead.
The Wild Horse is a real horse’s skull, painted black and with its jaws wired so it can ‘snap’ its teeth at the audience. It mounted on a pole, held by a man bent double under a canvas cover. According to Wilfred Isherwood, a member of the gang in the 1970s, they acquired the horse’s head from the Hatton gang during the 1920s. It was a tradition that whenever groups passed each other they would try to pinch the other gang’s horse’s head:
The Antrobus Soul Cakers have a long and distinguished history. A local team is known to have performed up to the First World War, and the group was revived in the late 1920s at the instigation of Major A. W. Boyd. The Soul Cakers have been performing regularly ever since, and they are now one of the few mumming groups in Cheshire.
Major Boyd’s home at Frandley House became the first stop on their Halloween round. The article above describes that Boyd requested in his will that the gang should perform their play one final time in the old mansion house:
“We did as he wished, and performed the play to an audience of two.
David Goulburn, Antrobus Soul Caker 1973
They were the people who were winding up the Major’s affairs at the house. I don’t think they really knew what was going on.”
The words to the play have been handed down over the years, and Boyd took note of the Comberbach version and wrote it down, together with their song:
Why the dates?
The precursor to modern ‘trick or treating’, souling marks the three days centred around All Hallows’ Day – November 1. Long ago, people believed that the walls between the living and dead were very thin at this time of year.
The Christian church adopted November 2 as All Souls Day and November 1 All Saints (Hallows) Day, making October 31 All Hallows Eve. The three days were celebrated by eating special cakes, called soulcakes. A tradition developed for children to go from house to house, singing and asking for soulcakes. Later in certain areas, especially Cheshire, this changed into the performance of mumming plays by groups called soul cakers.
What are Soul Cakes?
In a recent article by English Heritage: a Soul Cake, also known as a soulmass-cake, was a small round cake (although more like a biscuit), traditionally made using oats and may have been spiced with nutmeg, cinnamon and ginger, as well as raisins or currants. If you want to try to make some, the recipe is here.
And Antrobus Community Community Shop and Tea Room has also revived the making of the soulcakes:
Soul Caking over the last 80 years
From the transcripts of an academic study in the 1970s and from newspaper articles, it’s clear that keeping the tradition alive has been hard fought. Following the encouragement from Major Boyd in the 1920s, the gang was revived again during 1947/48 from Antrobus Youth Club. At that time there were gangs in Hatton, Stockton Heath, Budworth, Barnton and Comberbach. In the past, performances were usually in private houses with beer and cake, since the 1970s they’re now performed in pubs (see the poster below for 2023). The tradition that still continues to this day is that the gang don’t rehearse, and that sons often follow in their father’s footsteps. During the 1950s/60s members of the Antrobus gang at that time talked about internal disputes as well as loss of members to other interests, compounded by newcomers to the village and an indifference of new local people to the custom. To keep the custom alive, during the 1960s the Antrobus Soul Cakers performed in a film for the English Folk Dance and Song Society. They performed in Liverpool, Manchester, Crewe, Frodsham, Warrington and Knutsford.
In this later article written in 1997, Edward Isherwood recounts his memories of 50 years of being a member of the Antrobus Soul Cakers. The image which is hard to see below is his grandfather Edward Plumb hanging onto a goat with other members of Antrobus Soul Cakers back in the 1930s.
Fundraising
The Antrobus Soul Cakers have raised hundreds of pounds for charity over the years they’ve been performing.
The Soul Cakers Today
The Antrobus Soul Cakers perform every year in November, starting on All Souls’ Eve (1st November) and continuing for the following two weekends. The Antrobus Arms is now the home of the gang, always starting and finishing there each year – here is the 2023 itinerary:
And the answer to the question posed at the top whether Soul Caking had a future – is, thanks to the Antrobus community, a most definite yes!
Your memories
If you have memories or photos that you’d like to share, feel free to comment below or get in touch directly
References and acknowledgements
With thanks and acknowledgement, and for further reading:
A Country Parish by AW Boyd
Centre for Contemporary Legend – a couple of great articles about the Soul Cakers, one of which is ‘On photographing a most unruly horse’ https://contemporarylegend.co.uk/page/2/
The University of Leeds Special Sound Collections – I’ve not accessed these but there are many interviews from the 1970s: https://explore.library.leeds.ac.uk/special-collections-explore/409982
Know Your Cheshire: Antrobus Soul Cakers – article by Antrobus resident, Susan Sinagola: https://www.so-counties.co.uk/know-your-cheshire-antrobus-soul-cakers/
This lovely article by Sophie Parkes with photos from 2019: https://www.sophieparkes.co.uk/post/soul-soul-for-a-soul-cake
Calendar Customs – which lists the wide variety of traditional and unusual events that take place each year in the UK and to help visitors take part in them: